The headlines on used electric cars sound good. iSeeCars found that average prices for one- to five-year-old used EVs rose 9.8% year over year in September, to $32,533. Manheim's October data shows wholesale EV values up 6.6% from a year earlier. Used EV sales were up 73.2% year over year in October, according to CBT News.
CarCast's AI-powered forecasts point the other way. Across 106 well-listed EV segments, the average 60-day forecast is −1.69%, more than four times weaker than gas and hybrid vehicles (−0.38%). And it has gotten worse every month since September.
Both views can be true at the same time. Here's why.
How has the CarCast EV forecast changed since September?
These figures cover segments with at least 500 listing observations in the past four weeks and data from the last two weeks, with exotics excluded:
| Forecast run | EV segments | EV avg 60-day forecast | EV Sell signals | Gas and hybrid avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 20 | 101 | −1.17% | 31 | −0.19% |
| Oct 4 | 103 | −1.06% | 35 | −0.12% |
| Oct 18 | 104 | −1.25% | 35 | −0.28% |
| Nov 1 | 105 | −1.24% | 40 | −0.37% |
| Nov 8 | 105 | −1.49% | 46 | −0.36% |
| Nov 15 | 106 | −1.69% | 50 | −0.38% |
Almost half of all well-listed EV segments (50 of 106) are now rated Sell. That's up from 31 in September. Only 10 are rated Buy.
Why are year-over-year numbers up while the forecast is down?
Year-over-year numbers look backward. They compare today's prices with fall 2025, when used EVs were still falling after the federal tax credit expired. Beating a weak starting point is not the same as gaining value now. Month-to-month figures have already turned: Manheim's EV index fell 0.9% in October, and Cox reported that the average used EV listing price fell 1.8% in September to $36,767. Recurrent's retail data shows prices holding their 2026 gains but "steady over the last few months."
Our forecast looks forward, and more supply is coming. Deloitte projects that battery EVs will make up nearly 10% of all lease maturities in 2026 and about 25% in 2028. It also found that EV residual values are already tracking below expectations. Our model is picking up that supply. The model years most likely to be coming off lease have the weakest forecasts:
| Model year | EV segments | Avg 60-day forecast |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 8 | −1.37% |
| 2023 | 25 | −1.90% |
| 2024 | 37 | −2.20% |
| 2025 | 20 | −1.82% |
| 2026 | 9 | −0.36% |
The 2023 and 2024 model years match the timing of three-year leases ending, and they're the softest group.
Are luxury EVs losing value faster than mainstream EVs?
Yes, by a wide margin. For segments with deep listing data in both June and the past four weeks, here's how median asking prices have changed:
- Luxury-brand EVs (37 segments): −9.5% since June
- Mainstream-brand EVs (50 segments): −3.3% since June
The forward forecasts show the same gap, especially above $40,000:
| Group | Price band | Segments | Avg 60-day forecast | Buy | Sell |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Luxury brands | $25,000–$40,000 | 17 | −1.87% | 1 | 8 |
| Luxury brands | $40,000 and up | 30 | −2.98% | 1 | 21 |
| Mainstream brands | Under $25,000 | 12 | −1.16% | 1 | 3 |
| Mainstream brands | $25,000–$40,000 | 26 | −1.22% | 3 | 10 |
| Mainstream brands | $40,000 and up | 18 | +0.17% | 4 | 5 |
(Tesla is counted as mainstream here; Polestar, Lucid and Rivian are counted as luxury.)
Mainstream EVs priced over $40,000 average slightly positive. Luxury EVs at that price average nearly −3%, and 21 of the 30 are rated Sell.
Which used EVs have the weakest forecasts?
| Vehicle | Current median | Since June | 60-day forecast | Listings (4 wks) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 Chevrolet Equinox EV | $24,663 | −10.1% | −8.84% | 7,506 |
| 2023 Mercedes-Benz EQE SUV | $35,998 | −10.7% | −8.60% | 3,612 |
| 2023 BMW i7 | $58,886 | −11.5% | −7.42% | 942 |
| 2024 BMW iX | $46,581 | −11.1% | −6.27% | 4,848 |
| 2024 Audi Q8 e-tron | $37,247 | −14.2% | −6.20% | 3,648 |
| 2025 Nissan Leaf | $16,655 | −21.0% | −6.17% | 4,171 |
| 2024 Polestar 2 | $24,197 | −22.6% | −5.96% | 4,065 |
The 2025 Leaf and 2024 Polestar 2 have already fallen more than 20% since June and are still rated Sell. The 2024 Equinox EV stands out as a mainstream model with a weak forecast. It has the most listings of any EV on this list, which suggests supply is the issue, not demand for the brand.
Which used EVs are still forecast to rise?
These are the top Buy signals among well-listed EVs:
- 2026 Chevrolet Blazer EV, $40,696: +9.42%
- 2021 Tesla Model S, $44,990: +3.87%
- 2025 Ford Mustang Mach-E, $39,400: +3.77%
- 2024 Toyota bZ4X, $24,990: +3.51%
- 2024 Audi Q4 e-tron, $31,120: +3.34%
- 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5, $32,988: +2.98%
- 2024 Ford F-150 Lightning, $52,016: +2.25%
Six of the seven are from mainstream brands. The Q4 e-tron is the only luxury-brand EV on the list, and at about $31,000 it's priced like a mainstream car.
What should EV buyers and sellers do now?
Buyers shopping for a luxury EV: Wait. 2023–2024 BMW iX, Mercedes EQE SUV and Audi Q8 e-tron models are already down 10% to 14% since June, and our forecasts point another 6% to 9% lower over the next 60 days. More of them will come off lease into 2027.
Buyers who want a mainstream EV now: The Ioniq 5, bZ4X and Mach-E are rated Buy and are firming. You probably won't get a much better price by waiting.
Sellers: If you own a 2023–2024 luxury EV, selling before more lease returns arrive likely beats holding through the winter.
Dealers: Pricing that relies on year-over-year comparisons may be overstating EV values. Price off-lease luxury EVs to current market comps, not last year's.
You can search any EV on CarCast for its 60-day forecast and listing depth, compare our numbers with KBB and Edmunds, or see what each CarCast plan includes. For more background, see our earlier analysis of luxury EV depreciation.