Why Used Car Prices Are About to Rise: A Data-Driven Analysis
Our models are flagging an unusual confluence of signals. This doesn't happen often -- but when it does, dealers who position early win.
Signal 1: Off-Lease Supply Dip
The COVID-era production halt (2021-2022) created a supply hole that's now hitting the 3-year lease return cycle. Off-lease supply for 2022 model year vehicles is tracking 18% below 2025 levels for the same period.
Less supply at auction means higher floor prices. This is especially pronounced for trucks and midsize SUVs where lease penetration was highest.
Signal 2: Tariff-Driven New Car Price Premium
With average new car prices up $3,200 vs. pre-tariff levels, buyer pressure is pushing down market. This demand spillover typically takes 8-12 weeks to move segment-level prices.
We're currently in week 6 of this spillover cycle. The models are picking up early price momentum in the most substitutable segments: used trucks, compact SUVs, and mainstream sedans.
Signal 3: Spring Seasonal Demand
Historically, used car demand rises 6-9% from February through May across all segments. Tax refund season (February-April) drives first-time buyers into the market, and improving weather increases dealership foot traffic.
What Our Models Show
When we combine these three signals, CarCast's AI forecasting model projects:
- Trucks (F-150, Silverado, RAM): +4-6% over 60 days
- Compact SUVs (RAV4, CR-V, Tucson): +3-5% over 60 days
- Mainstream Sedans (Camry, Accord, Civic): +2-4% over 60 days
- Luxury Sedans: Flat to slightly negative (demand shift is away from luxury)
- EVs: Continued downward pressure (-2-5%)
What Dealers Should Do
- Stock up on trucks and SUVs now -- acquisition costs will rise
- Be cautious on luxury and EVs -- these segments are counter-trending
- Watch the weekly forecast -- our model updates every Sunday with fresh data
- Set price alerts -- get notified when specific segments hit your target acquisition price
Track all 200+ segments with weekly AI forecasts. Start your free trial